As I despair over the level of discourse already evident in the first few days of the 2008 presidential campaign, I'm trying to figure out why intellecuals and ideas are so despised.
The arguments I heard from the Republicans were almost entirely binary--either you're for something or against it, entirely, all the way, no middle ground. Either you love guns in all their glory for everybody, or you hate them and don't want anyone, anywhere, at any time to ever even be near them. And so on. Let's just not mention abortion.
I have always considered myself a populist. I love teaching first-year writing classes where I get students to engage in ideas and surprise themselves by how they can look at an issue from many sides and have lots of smart things to say. I grew up in a working-class family, where for whatever reasons, I found myself to be a passionate reader, and then found myself at a friend's house where her family sat around the dinner table and talked about ideas! Without yelling! Even though they disagreed!! I was truly stunned by the possibility of such a thing. With that same friend, I met kids from other schools who didn't just read books, they talked about them. I loved it. I think I've always wanted to KNOW stuff, all kinds of stuff, and I'm jealous when others know stuff I don't. I want to know it, too.
So why do people hate intellectuals so much? Why is it that I find pleasure from ideas despite my background but others don't? Why do I like asking questions, and others don't? Why do I love to talktalktalk with others, and others see it as so much hot air? Is it something that is hard-wired into us? I have egghead wiring and others don't? I was raised in a church that did not encourage critical thinking, yet I still manage to think critically. Why don't others do that, too?
I'm really worried about the state of our nation. I've read enough history to know that our country has always included a majority of folks who don't value knowledge just for the sake of knowledge. And I know that American pragmatism fuels our collective need for practical solutions to practical problems. But the widespread passion for Sarah Palin makes me sad. I want to have someone in office who knows more than I do, is smarter than I am, is curious about issues, and can change his/her mind when confronted by compelling evidence. When I go to a church, I want there to be a minister who knows more about the Bible and the ways that particular church interprets it than I do but can also listen to my concerns and questions without telling me I'm going straight to hell on the express train. If I hire a plumber, I want him/her to know WAY more about how plumbing functions to make my life mess-free. Why wouldn't folks want a smart president?
I don't want someone just like me. For one thing, that's about the last job I want. And for another, Palin and McCain AREN'T just like us at all. They are both driven and ambitious--as are all politicians who are willing to run seriously for a major office. I want someone smarter than me who wants the job. I want someone who can listen and learn. I want someone who can appreciate the complexity of his/her job and the complexity of the people he/she seeks to serve as well as to lead.
It's going to be a long road to November.